Problem #25

The increasing union problem for CBERs

Open!!High impact — resolution would likely be publishable in a top journal (Advances-level or above)

Suppose that EE is a CBER and there are hyperfinite CBERs E0E1E2E_0 \subseteq E_1 \subseteq E_2 \subseteq \ldots such that E=nNEnE = \bigcup_{n \in \N} E_n. Must EE be hyperfinite?

Definitions

A CBER, short for countable Borel equivalence relation is an equivalence relation EE on a Polish space XX such that EE is a Borel subset of X2X^2 and each equivalence class of EE is countable.

A CBER EE on XX is hyperfinite if there are CBERs E0E1E2E_0 \subseteq E_1 \subseteq E_2 \subseteq \ldots such that E=nNEnE = \bigcup_{n \in \N}E_n and for each nn, all of EnE_n's equivalence classes are finite.

Sometimes a CBER which is an increasing union of countably many hyperfinite CBERs is called hyperhyperfinite. Hence the question can be restated as asking whether every hyperhyperfinite CBER is hyperfinite.

Known Partial Results

Conley, Jackson, Marks, Seward and Tucker-Drob [CJMSTD23] showed that if a CBER EE is a generated by a graph which can be written as a countable increasing union of graphs of finite Borel asymptotic dimension (a stronger assumption than hyperfiniteness) then EE is hyperfinite.

Notes

This problem is connected to several other well-known problems about hyperfinite CBERs. For example, one such question is whether the collection of codes for hyperfinite CBERs is Σ21\Sigma^1_2-complete. Frisch, Shinko and Vidnyánszky [FSV24] have shown that if there is a hyperhyperfinite CBER which is not hyperfinite then this set of codes is Σ21\Sigma^1_2-complete.

Reference for the problem statement

[Kec25]Alexander S. Kechris, The theory of countable Borel equivalence relations, Cambridge Tracts in Mathematics, 2025

Additional References

[CJMSTD23]Clinton Conley, Steve Jackson, Andrew Marks, Brandon Seward and Robin Tucker-Drob, Borel asymptotic dimension and hyperfinite equivalence relations, Duke Mathematical Journal, 2023 [link] [doi]

[FSV24]Joshua Frisch, Forte Shinko and Zoltán Vidnyánszky, Hyper-hyperfiniteness and complexity, 2024 [link]

Comments

Loading comments…