Problem #2

Martin's Conjecture

Open!!!Very high impact — resolution would be of award-level significance

Work in ZF+AD+DC\mathsf{ZF} + \mathsf{AD} + \mathsf{DC}. Martin's Conjecture consists of the following two statements.

  1. Every Turing invariant function f ⁣:2N2Nf\colon 2^\mathbb{N} \to 2^\mathbb{N} is either Martin equivalent to a constant function or Martin above the identity function.
  2. The Martin order restricted to the Turing invariant functions which are Martin above the identity function is a prewellorder and the successor operation is given by the Turing jump—i.e. the successor of ff in the prewellorder is the function xf(x)x \mapsto f(x)'.

There is also a variant of the conjecture which can be stated in ZFC\mathsf{ZFC}, in which the functions considered are required to be Borel.

Definitions

  • A Turing invariant function is a function f ⁣:2N2Nf\colon 2^\mathbb{N} \to 2^\mathbb{N} such that for all x,y2Nx, y \in 2^\mathbb{N}, if xTyx \equiv_T y then f(x)Tf(y)f(x) \equiv_T f(y).
  • A cone of Turing degrees is a set A2NA \subseteq 2^\mathbb{N} of the form {y2NxTy}\{y \in 2^\mathbb{N} \mid x \leq_T y\} for some fixed xx.
  • The Martin order, denoted M\leq_M, is the partial order on Turing invariant functions defined by setting fMgf \leq_M g if there is some cone of Turing degrees such that for all xx in the cone, f(x)Tg(x)f(x) \leq_T g(x).
  • Turing invariant functions f,g ⁣:2N2Nf, g \colon 2^\mathbb{N} \to 2^\mathbb{N} are Turing equivalent if fMgf \leq_M g and gMfg \leq_M f. Equivalently, if for all xx in some cone of Turing degrees, f(x)Tg(x)f(x) \equiv_T g(x).
  • AD\mathsf{AD} refers to the Axiom of Determinacy. DC\mathsf{DC} refers to the Axiom of Dependent Choice.

Known Partial Results

  • Steel proved the second part of the conjecture for functions which are uniformly Turing invariant. Later, Slaman and Steel proved the first part of the conjecture for such functions [SS88].
  • Slaman and Steel proved the conjecture for "regressive" functions—i.e. functions ff such that for all xx in some cone of Turing degrees, f(x)Txf(x) \leq_T x.
  • Slaman and Steel proved the second part of the conjecture functions which are order-preserving and Borel measurable. Later, Lutz and Siskind proved the first part of the conjecture for functions which are order-preserving.
  • Slaman and Steel constructed a counterexample to a version of Martin's Conjecture for the arithmetic degrees.

Notes

Martin's Conjecture was first posed by Donald Martin in the 1960s or 1970s and is one of the five original "Victoria Delfino" problems in descriptive set theory. It is sometimes claimed that it explains the phenomenon that all "naturally occurring" Turing degrees are simply the Halting Problem or its iterates.

There are several other well-known conjectures that either imply or contradict Martin's Conjecture, including Steel's Conjecture (which states that every Turing invariant function is Martin equivalent to a uniformly Turing invariant function) and Kechris's Conjecture (which states that Turing equivalence is a universal countable Borel equivalence relation and which is known to contradict Martin's Conjecture).

Reference for the problem statement

[MSS16]Andrew Marks, Theodore Slaman, and John Steel, Martin's conjecture, arithmetic equivalence, and countable Borel equivalence relations, Ordinal definability and recursion theory: The Cabal Seminar Vol. III, 2016 [link]

Additional References

[SS88]Slaman, T. and Steel, J., Definable functions on degrees, Cabal Seminar 81–85, 1988

[Mon19]Montalbán, A., Martin's conjecture: A classification of the naturally occurring Turing degrees, Notices of the AMS, 2019

Comments

Loading comments…