Problem #12

Weiss's Question

Open!!!Very high impact — resolution would be of award-level significance

Does every Borel action of a countable amenable group on a standard Borel space have hyperfinite orbit equivalence relation?

Known Partial Results

The conjecture has been proved for a number of special classes of amenable groups.

  • Weiss [Wei84] and, independently, Slaman and Steel [SS88], proved the conjecture for the group Z\mathbb{Z}.
  • Weiss (unpublished) proved the conjecture for groups of the form Zn\mathbb{Z}^n.
  • Jackson, Kechris and Louveau [JKL02] proved the conjecture for finitely generated groups of polynomial growth.
  • Gao and Jackson [GJ15] proved the conjecture for all countable abelian groups. Their methods were extended by Schneider and Seward [SS24] to prove the conjecture for all locally nilpotent groups.
  • Conley, Jackson, Marks, Seward, and Tucker-Drob [CJMSTD23] proved the conjecture for all polycyclic groups as well as groups whose finitely generated subgroups all have polynomial growth.

Notes

This question was originally asked by Weiss in [Wei84]. Part of Weiss's motivation was a theorem of Ornstein and Weiss which showed that if EE is the orbit equivalence relation of a Borel action of a countable amenable group GG on a standard Borel space XX then for any Borel probability measure μ\mu on XX, EE is μ\mu-hyperfinite. It follows that a counterexample to Weiss's conjecture would give an example of a countable Borel equivalence relation which is measure hyperfinite, but not hyperfinite.

Reference for the problem statement

[Kec93]Alexander S. Kechris, Amenable Versus Hyperfinite Borel Equivalence Relations, Journal of Symbolic Logic, 1993 [link] [doi]

Additional References

[Wei84]Weiss, Benjamin, Measurable dynamics, Contemp. Math, 1984

[CJMSTD23]Conley, Clinton T., Steve C. Jackson, Andrew S. Marks, Brandon M. Seward, and Robin D. Tucker-Drob, Borel asymptotic dimension and hyperfinite equivalence relations, Duke Mathematical Journal, 2023 [link]

[SS88]Theodore A. Slaman and John Steel, Definable functions on degrees, 1988

[SS24]S. Schneider and B. Seward, Locally nilpotent groups and hyperfinite equivalence relations, Mathematical Research Letters, 2024 [link]

[GJ15]Su Gao and Steve Jackson, Countable abelian group actions and hyperfinite equivalence relations, Inventiones Mathematicae, 2015

[JKL02]Steve Jackson, Alexander S. Kechris, and Alain Louveau, Countable Borel equivalence relations, Journal of Mathematical Logic, 2002

Comments

Loading comments…